04/15/05: The morning after
The Plain Dealer in Cleveland, Ohio and the Lonestar Times in Houston, Texas have thrown in their two cents.
“Note to would-be replacements: Do not question, on the air, in a heavily Catholic region, whether Pope John Paul II made it into heaven because he was not a ‘born-again’ Christian. Ironically, doing so has put Minto in radio purgatory.” – Chuck Yarborough, Plain Dealer
“While the station manager is certainly free to program in any way he sees fit, one wonders if this is another case of ‘Let’s play it safe.'”
“Fortunately for Houstonians there is little fear of boring ‘safe’ radio, as evidenced by the lively discussi
on of this story on KSEV [AM 700] during Mr. [Dan] Patrick’s show.” – Jeremy Weidenhof, Lonestar Times
Powerball reacted to the furor this morning.
“Well, the story is all over the place. ‘Pittsburgh Radio Host Fired For Wondering If Pope Went To Heaven’ My day started out with a phone call about an AP article that talked about Marty Minto. Then the Drudge Report picked it up. Then my phone started ringing with reporters from ABC and other national talk shows. Many of you have emailed me as well.”
“I’m going to say one thing and one thing only about all this. Don’t believe everything you read. That’s it. Nothing more. I have too much respect for everyone involved to push the issue. Most of you have been very kind to me. Some of you have accused me of being behind all this. Believe what you want to believe.”
“I have always said things happen for a reason. Both good and bad things. Sometimes it takes years to know what that reason is and when we do it’s just another reminder of who is really in control of our life.”
Marty and I certainly didn’t see eye-to-eye on theological issues, but he seemed like a great guy and he had a good radio presence (butchering of English aside). I will miss hearing his voice every day.
It’s funny, his anti-Catholic antics drove me up a wall and the plethora of emails I sent him probably annoyed him just as much. Now that I know that his show won’t be on anymore, I feel sick to my stomach and I’m feeling kind of misty-eyed. I would have liked to see him soften up a little on certain issues, not get fired.
WORD-FM has finally given an official comment.
“The story in Thursday’s Pittsburgh Tribune Review would lead you to believe that we ended Mr. Minto’s program because ‘He questioned if the pope’s Roman Catholic beliefs would impede his entry to heaven.’ This statement did not come from the management of WORD-FM. A similar headline accompanied an AP wire story that unfortunately was not fact checked. We have never placed any restrictions on subject matter for the talk show. Mr. Minto knows that. The decision to release Mr. Minto had been under consideration for an extended period, primarily because of our concern that he tended to unnecessarily alienate listeners; and was finalized well before the pope was in the news. The conclusion that he was released because of his views on the pope is completely without foundation. We regret that you were left with a perception that is false.” (emphasis mine)
I heard Marty crack jokes about nearly getting fired several times but I didn’t think much of it at the time. I guess he wasn’t kidding.
Christianity Today has picked up the story here.
Christians suing Christians proves that we do not take the gospel seriously. Plenty of non-Christians will have their ideas about Christianity confirmed if such a lawsuit is filed.
Come to think of it, there’s a lot of us Christians who will have their ideas about fellow Christians confirmed by that lawsuit.
Eric,
At least I’m self-employed. I can’t be fired for blogging what I think. How people react at church might be a different matter, but one I’m prepared to deal with.
How about you?
If Marty speaks with an attorney, that will be disappointing. Somehow, Christians suing Christians just looks real bad.
So tell me, how do we heal the Christian community and the Christians from this hurt?
It’s too bad. I would rather have a big Christian personality (okay, big with regard to Pittsburgh!) who would rally Catholics and Orthodox, rather than have a link on his personal website to “Good News for Catholics”, to teach us Catholics what the Bible really says. But we do need challenging folk as well, and I pray that this is not a symptom that WORD is becoming another easy-listening station, so to speak.
Phew! This is a ‘Hot’ one mate! Thanks for the link, deeply appreciated!
GBYAY
So was he fired because:
a) he called The Purpose-Driven [Insert Purpose-Deprived Thing] the moral, therapeutic, deistic schlock that it is?
b) because he was an ill-informed anti-Catholic bigot?
If (a) that really is too bad, and confirms my thesis that “safe” Christian Radio is anything but… If (b) then… well… that still seems like no reason to fire him. Seems we still all benefit from folks stirring up the stew a bit…
We have a “Christian” Radio station here in N. Jersey that goes on-and-on now about how “safe for your whole family” they are. But I really have to wonder just how “safe” their milk-toast programming and profoundly insipid music really is… I have to wonder how many people will try to enter by the wide gate and broad way exactly because it seemed “safe.” “Safe” is exactly what mainstream CCM and X-ian broadcast radio is trying to be… and I can’t help but wonder just how dangerous being “safe” really is… Give me bare boobs @ the Superbowl anyday over this…
Cheers!
We live in a predominantly Christian country. Christians sue Christians every day, and it does no remarkable harm.
Also, I don’t know that non-Christian radio stations pose a particular threat to children. We spend an awful lot of time and energy protecting children from some media threat which has never really been demonstrated to exist.
test
[…] Jerry Bowyer and the Catholic Church By Funky Dung Jerry Bowyer’s attitude toward the Catholic Church is definitely a lot better than his predecessor’s. Here are some podcasts from his show. “Jerry interviews Ronald Rychlak, author of ‘Righteous Gentiles: How Pius XII And the Catholic Church Saved Half a Million Jews from the Nazis’, about the tremendous sacrifice European Catholics made to resist Hitler and save Jews, and dispels the myths that Hitler was Christian and that Christians turned a blind eye to the Holocaust. “ “Jerry interviews George Weigel, author of ‘God’s Choice : Pope Benedict XVI and the Future of the Catholic Church,’ about Benedict and his path from priest to pontiff.” “Jerry interviews Father Richard John Neuhaus, editor-in-chief of First Things, about the long-standing relationship between the Catholic Church and the Democratic Party, and where they will go from here.” “Jerry interviews Raymond Arroyo, the host of ‘The World Over Live’ on the Enternal Word Television Network, about Christian journalism.” […]
[…] I’ve been listening to the Jerry Bowyer Program on WORD-FM fairly often these days. Jerry replaced Marty Minto, who was fired under contentious circumstances. On the whole, I like the show. I like tone and style and I think Jerry handles callers well. There’s a good balance between charity and patience on the one hand and avoiding time-wasting arguments with nuts on the other. When he talks about Christian topics, I enjoy listening to him and calling the show. Something worries me, though. […]
[…] April 21st, 2005 by Funky Dung Once again, my overactive mouth (or in this case, keyboard) has gotten me in trouble. A rather unpleasant affair occurred at Evangelical Underground. When time permits, I will be publishing an apology to all involved. I will also be apologizing for snide comments I made in my Marty Minto post. My sincere hope is that valuable lessons have been learned by the participants and that those lessons can be passed on to our readers. Funky Dung […]
[…] Ever wonder what Marty Minto's been up to? […]